Katherine Graff's UTA Web Page

Synthesis of Research Findings V
Home
About Me
EDUC 5329 Digital Portfolio
EDUC 5310 SP07
Contact Me

Competition in the Classroom

 

In general, males thrive in a competitive environment.  They tend to be louder and more dominating in their speech in class and will sometimes interrupt teachers or students to get their opinions heard.  (Hadaway, Online Reading, Section 6.7).  Girls are more comfortable in cooperative settings with less competition (Vandrick, www.tokyoprogressive.org.uk/gale/articles/vandrick.html).  I am assuming this draws from the nature of females to establish social connections and relationships during the communication process and the tendency of females to be quieter and shyer than their male counterparts. (Brown, 2002, pp259-260) Competition should not be eliminated from the curriculum, but perhaps limited in frequency within a class with both males and females.

 

 

Outside Risk Factors Related to Gender and Achievement

 

Boys tend to be labeled as bigger risk takers than women, but both sexes have outside factors that can influence their achievement.  For example, males and females have the risk of dropping out of school.  Males have a higher drop out rate, but females are less likely to return to school.  Girls are sexually harassed more and have the possibility of pregnancy.  A larger percentage of females suffer from depression than males, and often times this depression goes unnoticed or untreated. (Vandrick, www.tokyoprogressive.org.uk/gale/articles/vandrick.html)  Many boys experience developmental delays and are disciplined at a higher rate than their female classmates.   More boys than girls are assigned to special needs classes, and unfortunately, sometimes the recommendations are simply a “defect” with the teacher. (Hadaway, Online Reading, Sections 6.6 & 6.7)  All of these negative factors can sour motivational attitudes of students in language classes and effect overall achievement.  Awareness and knowing appropriate action for each situation seem to be the only defenses against demotivation and subsequently transfer.

 

The Hidden Influence of Text

 

The AAUW has been closely monitoring the progress of diversity with in educational texts, and more specifically gender.  There remains a large concern by the AAUW that women’s roles in textbooks are an additive approach rather than a transformation or social action approach (B & K, pp 118-120).  Interestingly, Vandrick states that persons who are discriminated against because of gender are usually discriminated because of another intersecting diversity factor such as race, ethnicity, or class as well.  (Vandrick, www.tokyoprogressive.org.uk/gale/articles/vandrick.html) 

Texts should include both genders and all multicultural persons portrayed in non-traditional, non-stereotyped roles in a positive fashion to combat the socialized roles.

 

 

Previous Page  SRF IV                  Research Alert Home                    Next Page TipSheet

If you need assistance navigating this website or encounter missing or broken links, please contact me at malakasagira@yahoo.com .

lkasjdhlakjs

Horizontal Divider 12

 

IX.

 

5329 Portfolio Rubric

 

 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
If you need assistance navigating this website or encounter missing or broken links, please contact me at malakasagira@yahoo.com .